One reply to the argument comes from robert adams 1972, who contends that there is no moral obligation to create the best. Consequentialism definition of consequentialism by. Stephen hawkings a brief history of time bantam press was written by the late carl sagan, a leading american physicist who was also atheist. Cism study guide christian reina, cissp, cisa, crisc 2010 an investment in knowledge pays the best interest. Philippa foot utilitarianism and the virtues mind 94 1985 196209. Consequentialist theory is one of the normative ethics theories that try to answer the ethical questions about right or wrong and how we arrive at this answer. Consequentialism assesses the rightness or wrongness of actions in terms of the value of their consequences. Legitimate locutions, apparitions, visions, and burning bushes, and the like which are undoubtedly mixed in with the fabrications of hucksters and the selfinduced frenzies of the overly pious, are responses to, or descriptions of, mystical experiences, wherein one encounters the isness of reality in a way that transcends our normal sense.
This article distinguishes and examines three main relevant kinds of appeals to psychological realism. Suppose i get another cavity, and two dentists are equally good and available. Read consequentialism and cluelessness, philosophy and public affairs on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Traces of utilitarian thought can be found in the works of plato and aristotle, but not until the eighteenth century did utilitarianism truly begin to emerge as a welldefined and. Religionin the sense of a faith system that establishes parameters for good and evilis just as necessary as science. The fallacy of open theism open theism sometim es ca lled freewill theism or open ness theolo gy is the unscriptural belief that god does not know the future perfectly, but only imperfectly. But it seems reasonable to worry that largerscale actions will tend to have comparably greater hidden consequences, in which case it is not clear that cowens argument overcomes the cluelessness objection. Utilitarianism has frequently been criticized for lacking psychological realism, but what this means and why it is thought to matter varies. Registration process step 1 fill in the registration form at the end of this document and send it to hellenic american union by. Rational action and explanatory consequentialism don tontiplaphol.
Consequentialism 46 utilitarianism 47 criticisms of utilitarianism 48 negative utilitarianism 51 criticism of negative utilitarianism 52 rule utilitarianism 52 virtue theory 53 criticisms of virtue theory 54 applied ethics 55 ethics and metaethics 58 naturalism 59 criticisms of naturalism 59 moral relativism 61 criticisms of moral relativism. An argument for consequentialism 401 principle along these lines must be accepted in order to explain why the above argument is valid. Consequentialism is the class of normative ethical theories holding that the consequences of ones conduct are the ultimate basis for any judgment about the rightness or wrongness of that conduct. Subjective consequentialism and cluelessness in light of epistemic considerations, many consequentialists favour a move to subjective consequentialism. How to put multiple documents into one pdf pdf combine. Theories of ethics thomas lombardo within human history and continuing into present times, we. Find materials for this course in the pages linked along the left. A muslim response to stephen hawkings latest pronouncements about god by usama hasan, 7th september 2010 the introduction to the original 1988 edition of prof. This lack of appreciation is, i suspect, partially due to historical happenstance. Consequentialism definition is the theory that the value and especially the moral value of an act should be judged by the value of its consequences. James lenman, consequentialism and cluelessness, philosophy and public. Sep 07, 2010 what breathes fire into the equations.
It received a fair amount of favourable comment at the time. Where the variety and number of farmed animals and wild animals have raised cluelessness and demandingness challenges for consequentialism, future. Clues for consequentialists utilitas cambridge core. Thus, from a consequentialist standpoint, a morally right act or omission from acting is one that will produce a good outcome, or consequence. K10601 uk isaca cism certification certified information security manager courseware courseware version 6. You shall not use a pdf reader just to copypaste it into word. Introduction in an important and forcefully argued article, james lenman has claimed that consequentialism, which is the view that the rightness or wrongness of an act is determined by its total overall. Data were gathered through ten indepth interviews with six south african business leaders commended to be champions of integrity. However, most are clueless about how to proceed with. Journal of workingclass studies volume 2 issue 2, dec 2017 hurst 161 williams, joan 2017 white working class. Consequentialism, metaphysical realism, and the argument from cluelessness at the international society for utilitarian studies isus xi, lucca, italy, june, 2011. Study 27 terms psychology chapter 14 flashcards quizlet.
More specifically, gundry argues that mark portrays. Thus, from a consequentialist standpoint, a morally right action is one that produces a good. The methodology of ahlussunnah wal jamaaah in criticizing. Rather than being the enemy of science, true religion humanizes and civilizes it and keeps it from creating monsters. Pdf utilitarian and deontological ethics in medicine. The belief that consequences form the basis for any valid moral judgment about an action. Lang 2008 cluelessness and indifference the journal of. A conceptual framework of integrity abstract this article reports on the findings of a qualitative study in which the construction of integrity of some business leaders was explored. James lenman is a lecturer in philosophy at the university of glasgow. One of the controversies that have created a bit of a stir in evangelical theological circles in recent. Pahls christianity appeals to history, and to history it must go. In our zeal to live as god requires, we will at times take on more restrictions than god has placed upon us. Recommendations for additions to the list are welcome.
Pdf consequentialism and nonhuman animals tyler m john. Mans freewill, the power of prayer and how god has. What sets utilitarianism apart from other types of consequentialism is that it maintains that we must consider the consequences for everyone at least all humans, perhaps all sentient beings. Annotated list of ethical theories the following list is selective, including only what i view as the major theories. Contemporary readings i am very impressed with this collection. Project muse analytic philosophy, theism, and contemporary. Consequentialism and cluelessness consequentialism and. Decisions, whether moral or prudential, should be guided at least in part by considerations. Sorry, we are unable to provide the full text but you may find it at the following locations. Consequentialism is the class of normative ethical theories holding that the consequences. The ultimate online source to find big name textbooks used in schools. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
Kraays 20 newman lecture, method and madness in contemporary analytic philosophy of religion is a valuable survey of and interaction with four recent works by philosophers of religion, each of which advances arguments concerning how philosophy of religion ought to be pursued, given the relatively high percentage of theists in the field. Through empirical means consequentialism seeks the most desirable ends good for mankind. An archive for the fallacy files weblog for may, 2007, it describes and gives examples of logical fallacies from the media and everyday life, applying logic to controversial issues in order to improve critical thinking skills. Existentialism, globalisation and the cultural other. In particular, i argue that there is very good reason to believe that the problem of cluelessness for consequentialism is only as embarrassing for consequentialism as the spectre of.
The condition of postmodernity autonomous learning. Indeed, it will never be possible to say for sure that any given act was right or wrong, since any event can continue to. Entries in bold face have been especially influential. But in addition, it would create credit problems that must not be overlooked. It isnt saying much to claim that morality is demanding. In the sequence of misess books concerning policy, this book followed socialism, and was the first to present a new theory of interventionism. Posts viewing 1 post of 1 total you must be logged in to reply to this topic. A history of racism and heterosexism at colby an honors thesis submitted to the colby college department of history by alyson lindquist. Racial and cultural otherness universal publishers. If that were so, one would just go on for ever, and there would be an obviously hopeless regress. Ethics handout 14 notes on lenman, consequentialism. Sophisticated consequentialism and psychological coherence. In summary, consequentialism looks at the result of ones chosen action as the norm for how one ought to act. Theism and deism search for answers november 1, 2015 john babich, presenter.
Sophisticated consequentialism and psychological coherence in alienation, consequentialism, and the demands of morality, peter railton introduces an approach to consequentialism that has since become influential. They might talk only about public rules and not consider deep morality at all. Broad called selfreferential altruism and associated with commonsense morality 1953. Consequentialism, cluelessness, and indifference introduction in an important and forcefully argued article, james lenman has claimed that consequentialism, which is the view that the rightness or wrongness of an act is determined by its total overall consequences, is exposed to a crippling di. Consequentialism, cluelessness, and indifference core. Credo ut intelligam 2 1 beyond ideology and utopia.
Consequentialism and cluelessness, philosophy and public. Booty although anglicanism has no theologian comparable to thomas aquinas for the roman catholics, luther for the lutherans, or calvin for,the calvinists, there have been certain theological writers whose works have been widely regarded as, in some sense, standards not only for faith and. March 29, 2014 abstract it is common in political science to assume a quasihumean picture of rational action. Utilitarianism is one of a group of theories that maintain that the rightness or wrongness of an actio n depends on the actions consequences. Theories of ethics center for future consciousness. Many of you may have multiple pdf documents that you need to put into one single coherent pdf file. Consequentialism, cluelessness, and indifference gerald lang department of philosophy, university of leeds, woodhouse lane, leeds ls2 9jt, uk. Consequentialism and cluelessness consequentialism and cluelessness authors james lenman source philosophy public affairs vol 29 no 4autumn 2000 pp. Black catholic theological symposium bcts international network of societies of catholic theology triennial network council meeting depaul university chicago, il u. But it may stray too far from the spirit of consequentialism consider again my example of the reasons for giving to famine relief, which dont seem to depend on whether the famine was caused by another agent corrupt govt or by, say, drought. Consider isaca membership if you are not yet an isaca member, you should consider joiningwhen you register for this exam and purchase study aids, you can save money now. Geol chapter 1 earth as a system flashcards quizlet.
This aphorism, attributed to the late oxford biblical scholar, george caird, aptly. The structure of consequentialism no one can hold that everything, of whatever category, that has value, has it in virtue of its consequences. If so, consequentialists have no quarrel with them. It seems to me to have great pedagogical value on its own, and it would work splendidly with. Consequentialism, egoism, and the moral law 1 contemporary ethical theorists consider kants arguments in the groundwork and the critique of practical reason as straightforwardly anticonsequentialist, it is important to correct this misconception. This is unsurprising given aristotles status in the profession, the extensive treatment of virtue found in the nicomachean ethics, and the centrality of virtue to aristotelian ethics as compared to its. Lecture notes ethics linguistics and philosophy mit. The epistemic objection to consequentialism says that it cannot provide practical action guidance because the full consequences of our actions are unknowable. James lenman, consequentialism and cluelessness, philosophy and public affairs 29 2000. Consequentialism, deontology, ethics, and virtue the. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext.
Lenmans argument from cluelessness against consequentialism is that a significant percentage of the consequences of our actions are wholly unknowa we use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. University of kansas 1445 jayhawk boulevard wescoe hall. Consequentialism is the view that actions should be evaluated morally on the basis of their consequences. What has been said here applies to every attempt at transferring private enterprises, especially the banking system, into the hands of the state, which in its effects would amount to allround nationalization.
People who embrace open theism have severely limited g ods attributes. Cluelessness objection revisited proceedings of the. Ethics syllabus fall 2017 central european university. His recent published work includes michael smith and the daleks. Given the radical uncertainty associated with the longrun consequences of our actions, consequentialists are sometimes clueless. Consequentialism and the principle of indifference 317 lenmans argument is supposed to undermine both objective and subjective forms of consequentialism. On this picture, an action is rational if and only if it is such as to be caused by a rationalizing set of mental states. Consequentialism, metaphysical realism and the argument. An archive for the fallacy files weblog for october, 2007, it describes and gives examples of logical fallacies from the media and everyday life, applying logic to controversial issues in order to improve critical thinking skills. Neblo department of political science ohio state university march 2nd, 2015 william minozzi, associate professor, william. Such theories arise in religion, spiritual traditions, philosophy, socialpoliticalhistorical systems, literature and the humanities, social and cultural movements, and pop psychologies. Consequentialism and integrity 21 tialism that the only.
Existentialism, globalisation and the cultural other gavin sanderson flinders university gavin. What about the epistemic argument against consequentialism, either maintaining its nonviability as a decision procedure or more profoundly as an argument against the criterion of rightness view, on the grounds that it would seem to leave open or epistemically uncertain the rightness or wrongness of actions for which we are certain of the actions status as right or. Ethics handout 14 notes on lenman, consequentialism and. Desiresatisfaction, time, and the argument from internalism at the american philosophical association, pacific division, april, 2011. Consequentialism is the analysis of the expected benefit of the results for a given course of action.
948 1187 367 754 1324 769 941 529 846 326 50 1317 1161 962 1552 921 171 1477 542 1015 706 1443 920 1317 907 1212 479 474 987 433 1162 1321 681 1588 400 1575 397 317 1378 982 154 52 1272 695 148 234 975 495 177